Tuckpointing and Repointing
Fackrell Masonry and Construction repoints brick, block and stone across southern Idaho, cutting failed mortar out of the joints on chimneys, houses and commercial buildings and packing in new mortar mixed to match the original color.
Repointing replaces the mortar, not the brick. The mortar joints are the part of a wall that wears out first. They crack, pull apart and wear away. Once they've worn back far enough, the brick has to do work the mortar was supposed to be doing. Fixing that before brick starts falling out costs a whole lot less than fixing it afterward.
Color is the hard part, and I'll tell you why. You can't get an exact match on an old wall. The original mortar has been weathering in the Idaho sun for decades, so it isn't the color it was when it was mixed. Some of what went into it isn't made or mined anymore. My dad and I built our own set of sample mortars over years of trial and error, and it gets us to about 75%. That's close enough that the repair looks like part of the wall instead of a patch.
Repointing also shows you what else is loose. Once the joints are open, the loose brick and stone are easy to spot. That's the time to reset them, instead of waiting for one to work its way out on its own. When the wall's finished and the afternoon sun is across it, good repointing is hard to find.
What this covers
- Cracked, separated and eroded mortar cut out of the joints, and the dust cleaned out of them. The National Park Service standard, Preservation Brief 2, is to cut back two to two and a half times the width of the joint. If the cut is shallow, or the dust is left in the joint, the new mortar has nothing to bond to, no matter how good the mix is
- Mortar matched as closely as the materials allow, worked out from a cured sample set my dad and I have built up over the years. About 75% is a realistic match, and on a wall where color really matters, I can hold cured chips against it in daylight to compare
- Mortar mixed no harder than the masonry around it. A modern high-strength mix in a soft old wall doesn't help the wall, it destroys the brick. Something has to give, and it won't be the mortar
- A whole wall, post or pillar repointed where a spot repair would look like a patch
- Loose brick and stone found once the joints are open, which usually makes sense to reset while I'm there
- Earlier repairs that were done wrong, put right. For example, cracks packed with globs of mortar instead of being cut out and repointed properly
- Chimney repointing, including rebuilding the top where the joints have gone entirely
- Whole-house and whole-building repointing, usually worked one side of the building at a time so the job stays manageable and the color stays consistent
- Commercial work, including storefronts and brick planters, washed down and cleaned up when the work is finished instead of left for somebody else
Wondering what masonry repairs usually cost? See my cost guide.
How to tell you need this
- Joints worn back from the face of the brick. A quarter of an inch is where the trade says it's time to repoint, because past that the joint stops shedding water.
- Deep holes or voids in the joints, where mortar has washed out well behind the face of the wall.
- Tooled joints with the hard outer surface worn away. Tooling means the mason pressed and shaped the joint with a tool, which packs the surface down hard. That hard skin is what sheds water. Once it's gone, the softer mortar behind it wears away a lot faster. Raked joints (set back from the face of the brick) don't have that skin, so on those it's just a question of how deep the wear goes.
- Mortar you can pick out with a fingernail. Joints wear back over time, and when the mortar comes away in crumbs, the wall is overdue.
- Open cracks running through the joints. On commercial buildings I regularly find gaps wide enough to take a knife blade, running all the way around the building, on walls that look perfectly sound from the parking lot.
- A brick or stone that moves when you push on it. The joints around it have failed, and repointing is how I find the rest of the loose ones and reset them before one comes out of the wall.
- Repointing that still looks new, but the new mortar is coming out of the joints in clean, whole chunks. Mortar is meant to wear away slowly, in crumbs, over decades. When it comes out in tidy pieces you could nearly stack back up, that isn't age. That's mortar that never bonded, and it means the joints were cut too shallow, never washed out, or both.
- A previous repair that looks wrong. A stair-step crack packed with a glob of mortar instead of cut out and repointed, or mortar left across the brick faces. The packed crack has to be done over. The smeared faces, if they've been there more than a week, are permanent.
- Patchy, mismatched mortar left behind by an old spot repair. Where the color never matched, repointing the whole wall or post is what makes it even again.
Questions people ask
Do you do tuckpointing in Nampa and Boise?
Yes. The service area is all of Southern Idaho, between the Oregon and Wyoming borders, reaching as far north as McCall, Stanley, New Meadows and Salmon. I work from Nampa in the Treasure Valley and Blackfoot in eastern Idaho. Houses, commercial buildings and public buildings all the same. Send the job over by clicking here.
What's the difference between tuckpointing and repointing?
In everyday use, nothing. Most people use both words for the same job, and so do plenty of masons. Ask for either one and I'll know what you mean.
The real difference is still worth knowing. Repointing is the repair. The failed mortar comes out of the joints and fresh mortar goes in. That's what keeps water out of the wall. Tuckpointing was a decorative finish that started in England in the late 1700s. Fine brickwork had hairline white joints. If you couldn't afford that, you filled your joints with mortar to match the brick, scored a groove down the middle, and pressed a thin white ribbon of lime putty into it to look the part. It was never a repair. So nearly every job sold as tuckpointing in this country is really repointing.
The mortar between my bricks crumbles to dust when I touch it. How bad is that?
It's overdue, but it's usually still the cheap version of this job.
Mortar is meant to wear away slowly. That's its job. It's the soft part of the wall, so it takes the movement and the weathering instead of the brick taking it. Powdery mortar you can rub away with a thumb has just about run its course. Most people say it looks like the mortar turned to sand, and that's a good way to put it.
What matters is how deep it goes. A quarter inch back from the face of the brick is where the trade says it's time to repoint, because past that the joint has stopped shedding water. Poke a screwdriver into the joint and see how far it goes before it hits something solid. If it's half an inch of dust, you're well past due. If it goes in and keeps going, water is already getting behind the wall.
The good news is that you're asking before the brick has started moving. Repointing while every brick is still where the mason put it is far and away the cheapest time to do this.
Is repointing worth doing before anything has fallen off?
Yes, and that's the best time to do it for the money. Once the joints have worn back far enough, the brick starts carrying weight the mortar was supposed to carry. From there the wall goes downhill a lot faster. Going in early means resetting a few loose bricks instead of rebuilding a section of wall, and mortar is cheap next to brick.
Should I repoint the whole wall or just the bad spots?
It depends on how much has failed and how much you care about it looking even.
On a single brick post, pillar or chimney, repointing the whole thing is usually the right call once roughly a third of the joints have gone. A patched third next to an untouched two thirds never quite looks like the same wall. That's a common request and a sensible one.
On a house or a larger building, the work usually goes one side at a time, and whatever has failed on that side gets repointed. Doing the full wall keeps the color the same across it, and that's what your eye actually picks up.
What does tuckpointing cost per square foot?
My cost guide has the range most repointing jobs land in.
Jobs often get quoted by the square foot, but on its own that number tells you very little.
Two walls with the same square footage can be very different jobs. Here's what changes the price. How many feet of joint are in it, since small brick has a lot more joint per square foot of wall than large block does. How deep the failure runs. How high the work is, because anything done from scaffolding or a lift carries the cost of getting up there. Whether the joints are tooled or raked, and how much the color match matters to you. And how much loose brick turns up once the joints are open, since it usually makes sense to reset it while I'm there.
There's a bigger problem with the number, though. A square foot rate says nothing about how deep the joint is being cut or whether it's washed out before new mortar goes in. Those two things decide whether the repointing lasts. A man cutting a quarter inch and skipping the wash can quote a very attractive rate.
So compare the work instead of the rate. Ask how deep they're cutting and what they do with the dust.
How long does repointing last, and how often does a house need it?
Done properly, decades. Not forever, because nothing outdoors lasts forever, but you shouldn't be buying it twice on the same house.
Nobody can give you a number of years that means anything, because the wall decides. A side of the house taking wind-driven rain and full afternoon sun wears faster than a sheltered side, which is why one side of a building is often ready while the other three are fine. Sprinklers hitting the same brick every morning will wear a wall out faster than the weather will.
So stop counting years and go look at the joints. Once they've worn about a quarter inch back from the face of the brick, they've stopped doing their job, whether that took twenty years or eighty.
The flip side is that repointing done badly can be finished inside two or three winters. If yours needs doing again soon after somebody did it, that isn't the wall's fault.
Can you repoint brick in the winter?
Some of it, with precautions. Some of it has to wait.
The problem is curing, which is the mortar hardening. Mortar that freezes before it cures never reaches the strength it was supposed to reach. It'll look fine, but it won't be, and nobody finds out for a few years.
So cold weather work takes real precautions. That means watching the overnight low instead of the afternoon high, warming the materials, and covering the work after it's laid. That's ordinary practice, and it's how commercial jobs keep running when the weather turns cold.
I'll tell you to wait when there's a hard freeze, or when a shaded wall won't get enough warmth for the mortar to get going. Waiting a few weeks costs you nothing. Repointing a wall twice costs you plenty.
If somebody offers to repoint your house in January and none of this comes up, that tells you what you need to know about him.
Will the new mortar match my old mortar?
Not exactly, and anybody who promises otherwise hasn't done much of this. The mortar you're matching has been weathering for decades, so it isn't the color it was when it was mixed, and some of what went into it isn't made or mined anymore.
My dad and I have spent years building a set of samples to work from. On a wall where color really matters, I can hold cured sample chips against the existing joints in daylight to compare. That gets us to about 75%. You don't need a perfect twin anyway. You want a repair that looks like part of the wall instead of a patch, and 75% does that.
Why is one repointing bid so much lower than another?
Because repointing is easy to fake, and the fake looks just like the real thing for the first couple of years.
The cheap version is to grind a quarter inch off the face of the joint, smear new mortar across it and call it done. It looks great in a photo. In Preservation Brief 2, the National Park Service puts the cut at two to two and a half times the width of the joint, and a quarter inch is nowhere near that.
The other half of that shortcut is skipping the wash. Cutting a joint fills it with dust, and mortar packed onto dust only bonds to the dust. Put those two shortcuts together and you get a failure I run into constantly. The repointing still looks new, but the mortar is backing out in clean, whole chunks you can pick out with your fingers.
Then there's the mix. Mortar harder than the brick won't give, so the brick does, and the faces start popping off. That damage is permanent, and the repair is what caused it.
None of this is expensive to do properly. It just takes time. The low bidder isn't cheaper because he found a better way. He's cheaper because he's doing half the work, and half the work at eighty percent of the price is a very good living. You're the one who ends up buying the job twice.
Before you pick anybody, there's a cheap check you can do. Get the state registration number from each bidder and look them up at the Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses. The trade on the registration should say masonry. A handyman code isn't a masonry qualification, it's just a form somebody filled in. A bidder with no registration at all isn't allowed to take the work in the first place. It won't tell you who's good, but it will thin the list out fast.
There's mortar smeared all over my brick. What does that tell me?
That whoever did it hadn't spent much time around masonry. You can tell from the sidewalk.
A thin line of mortar right at the edges of the brick is normal, and nobody avoids it. Mortar across the face isn't normal. The skill is keeping it off the face as you work, and knowing when to clean. Caught at the right moment, it comes away with almost no effort.
Miss that moment and it's over fast. Mortar soaks into brick like water into a sponge. After a few days it's very hard to remove. After a week, nothing will move it. No acid wash on earth will do it, and anything strong enough to try takes the face of the brick with it.
That's why smeared brick almost never comes from a mason. It usually comes from a chimney sweep, a handyman, or a general contractor doing repointing on the side. If you can go look at a crew's last job before you hire them, go look at it.
There's one more thing to do, and it takes two minutes. Ask for the state registration number and look it up at the Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses. Masonry should be the trade named on it. A handyman code isn't a masonry qualification, and nothing stops a handyman from taking on your repointing. But you're the one stuck with the result, and smeared brick stays with you for good.
Why is mortar falling out of my chimney or brickwork in large chunks?
Properly installed mortar wears away gradually, a little at a time. When it comes out in large chunks, the last repair was almost always done wrong.
The most common causes are joints that weren't cut out deep enough, mortar that is harder than the brick, joints that weren't cleaned or dampened first, and joints filled in one thick pass instead of thin layers. The standard is to cut old mortar out to two to two and a half times the width of the joint. A 3/8 inch joint should be cut out 3/4 to 1 inch deep. Shallow work has nothing to grip, so it pops out. Thin layers let the mortar cure evenly instead of shrinking away from the back of the joint. Weather matters too. Mortar that freezes or dries out too fast in wind or sun can fail early.
Another common cause is a skim coat of mortar smeared over the old joints without cutting anything out. That isn't a repair. It bonds poorly and falls off in pieces within a few seasons.
If mortar is coming out of your chimney in chunks, adding more on top won't fix it. The failed mortar has to be cut out and the joints redone correctly. I'm happy to look at it and tell you honestly what it needs.
Why is there mortar smeared on the face of my bricks?
Mortar smear on the face of the brick is one of the clearest signs of poor workmanship. A skilled mason keeps mortar in the joint, tools it cleanly, cuts off the extra, and brushes the brick face before the mortar hardens. Cleanup happens as the work goes, not weeks later.
Smear usually comes from hurried work, skipped cleanup, or a skim coat applied over the old joints without cutting them out first. It also makes joints look wider and messier than they really are. If the brick is smeared and the mortar is also falling out in chunks, that usually means the joints were never prepared properly. It points to the same failed repair.
Smear can often be cleaned off, but it has to be done carefully. Harsh acid cleaning used the wrong way can damage the face of the brick, so it's not a good place for guesswork or a pressure washer. If your brick has been smeared, I can look at it and tell you what's realistic.
Tuckpointing and repointing projects
Real jobs, my own photos, and what the problem actually turned out to be.
Chimney repair and whole-house repoint
A brick chimney rebuilt above the roofline and loose, eroding mortar repointed around the whole house, with the new mortar color-matched to the original.
Repointing a commercial building
Mortar joints on a commercial brick building cut out and repointed, from cracked wall sections to the brick planters out front, then washed clean.
Repointing and sealing a brick light post
A brick light post with failing mortar joints fully repointed, and the brick on the house sealed to slow further weathering.
Often needed alongside
Chimney repair
Rebuilds, crowns, flue liner work and repointing.
Chimney repair →Masonry sealing and commercial cleaning
Sealing for brick, stone and pavers anywhere. Cleaning on commercial size work.
Masonry sealing and commercial cleaning →Historical restoration
Landmark buildings repaired to match what is already there.
Historical restoration →