Chimney Repair and Rebuilding
Fackrell Masonry and Construction repairs and rebuilds brick and stone chimneys across southern Idaho, from crumbling crowns and loose brick to full rebuilds above the roofline. Brad Fackrell is a third-generation mason, working from Nampa and Blackfoot.
Almost every chimney problem I see starts with the crown. That's the masonry cap on top of the chimney's brick or stone, not the metal cap over the flue. It sheds water and keeps it out of the brick. A good, thick crown would have given most of these chimneys many more years. Most of them got a thin one instead. Once a thin crown cracks, water gets in at the top and runs down the face of the brick. That water breaks down the mortar between the bricks, and then the brick itself.
A chimney is out of sight and out of mind until bricks start raining down from above. By the time somebody contacts me, the top is usually worse than it looked from the ground. I regularly find the top few rows of brick lifting off with no effort at all. They're one wind storm away from coming down. The flue liner wears out too. That's the lining inside the chimney that the smoke travels up. By the time the old crown comes off, the top section of liner is often past saving.
Sometimes the fix is resetting the loose brick, repointing the joints, repairing the liner and building a new crown with a drip edge on it. Repointing means cleaning out the worn mortar between the bricks and packing in new. Other times the chimney is too far gone, and the right call is to take it down to the roofline and build it back. I can't tell you which one you need from the driveway. That gets decided once somebody has been up there.
What this covers
- Crowns cast in reinforced concrete, sloped away from the flue (the opening the smoke comes out of), and sticking out past the brick with a drip groove underneath. The Brick Industry Association calls for at least two inches thick at the thinnest edge, in Technical Notes 19B, Residential Chimneys. The drip edge throws water clear of the brick instead of letting it run down the face. On most chimneys, it's the cheapest way there is to add years to the brick below. It isn't right for every chimney, and Does every chimney get the same crown? further down covers the ones where it isn't
- Loose brick taken out and reset, and washed-out mortar joints repointed
- Mortar matched as closely as the materials allow. My dad and I have built up a set of cured mortar samples over the years, and the match gets worked out from those. About 75% is a realistic match. Nobody gets an exact match on a weathered chimney
- Top section flue liner repair, or replacement where a clay liner in the right size can be sourced. Pumice liners aren't made anymore, so on those the answer is a repair
- Metal chimney caps fitted on top of the flue liner. They keep rain out of the flue and stop birds and squirrels from moving into the chimney. People also call the masonry crown a cap, but that's a different part of the job
- Full rebuilds above the roofline, taken down to the roof and built back in brick or stone
- Rebuilds that suit the building, from Colonial corbelling, where the brick steps out row by row near the top, to engineered stone on a framed chimney
- Framed chimneys, called chases, covered in stone or brick, including full-height work from scaffolding on tall gable ends
- Repairs an insurance company wants done before it'll write or renew a policy. They come with photographs and a written description of what failed, because that's what the insurance company asks to see
- Protection for the roof around the chimney during demolition, so taking a chimney down doesn't cost you shingles as well
- Working with your roofer when flashing or a cricket is part of the fix. Flashing is the metal where the chimney meets the roof. A cricket is a small peaked section of roof built behind the chimney to send water and snow around it. Water at a chimney is a roofing problem about as often as it's a masonry one. Figuring out which one before anybody starts costs you nothing, and it saves you paying for the wrong repair
Wondering what masonry repairs usually cost? See my cost guide.
How to tell you need this
- Mortar joints worn back from the face of the brick. Once the mortar has worn back a quarter of an inch, the trade's standard says it's time to repoint. Past that point, the joint stops shedding water.
- On tooled joints, the hard outer surface worn away. Tooling means pressing the fresh mortar smooth with a jointing tool, and that packs the surface into a hard skin. The skin is what sheds water. Once it's gone, the softer mortar behind it wears away a lot faster. Raked joints don't have that skin, so on those it's just a question of how deep the wear goes.
- Daylight through the joints at the top of a chimney. That one's urgent. At that stage, brick is ready to start coming off.
- A cracked, crumbling or broken-up top. The top is what keeps water out of the chimney. On most chimneys around here, it's a thin wash: a layer of mortar troweled over the top, often thinned out to nothing at the edges. That thin edge is why the top fails first. Once it goes, the mortar joints and the brick below are next.
- Brick near the top you can move with your hand. Once the joints around it have washed out, there isn't much holding it in place.
- Brick or mortar crumbs on the roof and in the gutters. That material came off the top of the chimney. I regularly find the top few rows of brick lifting off with no effort at all. They're one wind storm away from ending up in the yard.
- A stucco or skim coat that's cracking and coming loose. A coating over loose, damaged brick isn't a repair. It's a bandaid, and bandaids over structural damage come off. The brick underneath is usually worse than the coating makes it look.
Questions people ask
Do you repair chimneys in Boise?
Yes. Fackrell Masonry and Construction covers all of Southern Idaho, between the Oregon and Wyoming borders. That reaches as far north as McCall, Stanley, New Meadows and Salmon. I work from Nampa in the Treasure Valley and Blackfoot in eastern Idaho. My work comes with a workmanship warranty, and you'll know its terms before you sign anything. Start with a quote by clicking here.
Do I need a mason or a chimney sweep?
They're two different trades. Mixing them up is one of the more expensive mistakes people make with a chimney.
A chimney sweep deals with the inside. They clean soot and creosote out of the liner so it doesn't catch fire. Creosote is the sticky, burnable tar that builds up from wood smoke. They also check whether it's safe to burn. That's their trade, not mine.
I deal with the chimney itself: the brick, the mortar joints, the crown on top and the top section of liner. I'm looking at whether it's standing up straight and whether it's shedding water.
Here's a rough rule. For smoke, a smell, or a safety check before burning season, you want a sweep. For something you can see from the yard, like loose brick, crumbs on the roof, a cracked top or a lean, you want a mason.
Where it goes wrong is hiring a sweep to do the masonry. Plenty of them will take the work, but repointing and crown work aren't what they do all day. I get hired to put it right often enough to say so plainly. You can usually spot it from the sidewalk, because mortar ends up smeared across the face of the brick. Once that mortar has hardened into the brick, nothing will take it off.
The problem is that a lot of sweeps call themselves masons, and most of them aren't. A real mason is a mason first. Now and then you'll find a mason who also sweeps chimneys, but it's uncommon, and they'll always lead with masonry in their advertising. So if the sweep cleaning your flue says "hey, we can fix your masonry too," that's your cue to have a mason look at it before anybody touches the brick.
Plenty of chimneys need both trades, and that's fine. Just don't hire one and expect the other one's work.
One more thing, and it's the part most people skip. Be careful when somebody says "well, we have a mason." I'd want to know who that mason actually is, what he's built, and how long he's been doing it. I'd also get the state registration number and look it up myself at the Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses. Idaho requires registration for construction work over a certain dollar amount, and almost any masonry job is over it. The registration lists the trade. Masonry should be on it.
No registration on a job that size isn't a small detail. It's against the law, and I'd run. If he's registered as a handyman, that tells you something too. A handyman registration is not a masonry qualification. Nobody takes an exam for it. Being a handyman doesn't stop somebody from taking on your masonry repair. It just means you're the one carrying the risk.
So the number is the bare minimum, not the whole answer. I'd check it, and then I'd still ask what he's built.
Why does my chimney smell like creosote on hot summer afternoons?
A creosote smell that's worst on hot summer afternoons is usually a draft or air pressure problem in the house, not a masonry one. A masonry inspection won't catch it. Figuring out what's wrong with a flue, the passage the smoke goes up, is a chimney sweep's trade, not mine. When your chimney stinks like that in summer, a qualified chimney sweep is who you want.
Here's what I'd tell the sweep and what I'd ask. How they answer tells you whether they understand the problem.
I'd tell the sweep the smell is worst on hot afternoons. I'd also mention it if a door opening, the air conditioner, or an exhaust fan running seems to go along with it, because any of those can be part of it.
Then I'd ask whether they check the house for air pressure problems, not just clean and brush the flue. I'd ask whether they'll run a camera down the chimney liner to look for cracks while they're in there. And I'd ask whether a top sealing damper makes sense for your chimney. That's a lid at the top of the chimney that closes when you're not using the fireplace, and it's a common fix for this kind of smell.
One more good sign is a sweep certified through the Chimney Safety Institute of America. It tells you they know what to look for.
I'd hire the sweep to clean the flue and check the inside, and nothing else, though. Plenty of sweeps advertise masonry work too, and most of them aren't masons. If one offers to fix your brick or mortar while they're up there, I'd get a mason to look at it first. There's more on telling the two apart under Do I need a mason or a chimney sweep?
Does my chimney need a repair or a full rebuild?
It comes down to how much damage there is, and how the cost of a repair compares to the cost of a rebuild. Mortar is the easy part. When joints wash out, they get repointed, and that alone rarely means a rebuild. Brick is what decides it. Once enough of the brick is ruined, replacing it piece by piece costs more than taking the chimney down to the roofline and building it back. At that point the rebuild is the cheaper job and the better one. That call gets made after somebody has actually been up there and looked.
My chimney is leaning away from the house. Is that dangerous?
I'd treat it that way until somebody has looked at it. A chimney that's moving can come down, and it doesn't give much warning.
Two very different things cause it. The first is the masonry. The joints have washed out so far that the chimney isn't holding together as one piece anymore, and the top half goes where gravity sends it. That's my work.
The second is what's underneath. The footing is the base the chimney is built on. If the footing has sunk or heaved, the chimney goes along for the ride and the house doesn't. I've been out to chimneys pulling away from a house where no amount of masonry would have fixed it, because the masonry was never the problem. Rebuilding a chimney on a footing that's still moving just starts the clock over.
Here's how to check yours. Look at the gap where the chimney meets the wall of the house. If it's wider at the top than at the bottom, and it's getting wider over time, that's the second kind. I'd take a photo today with a tape measure in the shot, then take the same photo in a month.
Water is showing up around my chimney. Is that a masonry problem or a roofing one?
It could be either one, and you'll want to know which before you pay anybody.
Water usually gets into a chimney one of three ways. One is the top, where a cracked or thin crown lets it straight down into the chimney. Another is the brick and the joints, where washed-out mortar lets it soak in from the side. The third is the flashing, the metal where the chimney meets the roof. The first two are mine. The third is roofing.
The stain on your ceiling won't tell you which one it is, because water runs sideways along the framing before it shows up inside. Somebody has to get up there and look at all three.
Figuring that out before anybody starts is the difference between fixing it once and paying for it twice. I'd rather send you back to your roofer than sell you a repointing job that doesn't stop the leak.
There's white chalky powder on my chimney. What is that?
It's called efflorescence, and it's salt. Water moving through the brick carries salt out to the surface. When the water dries up, the salt stays behind.
The powder itself is harmless, but what it means isn't. Water is getting into that chimney and moving through the brick. On a chimney, the usual way in is the top: a cracked crown, a thin wash that's failed, or mortar joints worn deep enough to soak up water.
I wouldn't count on it washing off, either. Some of it will and some of it never will. I'd try a small amount of water and a brush first. I mean small, because water is what caused this in the first place. Soaking the chimney to clean it makes the problem worse than the stain.
So it isn't really a cleaning problem. Scrubbing it off and sealing over it traps water that's still getting in, and that's worse than leaving it alone. Once the way in is found and closed, the powder stops coming back on its own.
If it keeps coming back after a rebuild or a repoint, water is still getting in somewhere up top.
Why do chimneys fall apart in the first place?
It usually starts at the top, and usually because whatever is up there was built too thin.
There are two ways to finish the top of a chimney. One is a crown. That's reinforced concrete cast in a form, sloped away from the flue, and sticking out past the brick with a drip groove underneath. The Brick Industry Association puts it at two inches thick at a minimum, in Technical Notes 19B. On most chimneys, a crown is the right answer. The other is a wash. That's material spread over the top with a trowel. Some chimneys are better off with a wash, usually where a crown would ruin what the original mason built.
The trouble is that almost nobody builds a wash properly. It gets thinned out to a knife edge where it meets the brick, and anything that thin cracks in the first hard freeze. Water gets in, runs down the face of the brick, and wears out the mortar joints. The material matters as much as the thickness. Plain mortar isn't very strong when it's spread thin, so a wash made out of it cracks even where nobody thinned it out.
That's how somebody gets to a cheap price. The top of a chimney is the one part of your house you'll never climb up and look at. A bad wash looks fine from the ground for the first few winters.
What does chimney crown repair cost?
My cost guide has the price range for most chimney repairs. A crown by itself is usually toward the low end of it. I'd still be careful with anybody who gives you a firm number before anybody has seen the chimney.
Two things move the price: how hard it is to get up there, and what's under the old crown. A one-story house with a roof you can walk on and solid brick underneath is one job. A steep two-story that needs scaffolding or a lift is another, and getting up there can cost more than the masonry does. Then there's what the old crown was hiding. Where water has been getting in for years, the top few rows of brick are usually loose, and those have to be reset or rebuilt. There's no point casting a good crown onto brick that's already coming apart.
A crown is cheap next to what it protects. It's a day or so of work. A rebuild above the roofline costs a whole lot more, and a bad crown is the most common reason people end up needing one.
Do you replace chimney flue liners?
Sometimes, and only the top section of each flue. The flue liner is the lining inside the chimney that the smoke travels up. When the crown comes off, the top section is the part that's taken the weather. If it needs replacing, I replace it, as long as I can source a clay liner to fit, and I usually can. The old pumice liners aren't made anymore, so on a pumice flue the answer is almost always a repair. The sections below the top are built into the chimney. Reaching them means taking the chimney apart, and that's a rebuild instead of a repair. I'll tell you that up front, not after.
Do you install chimney caps?
Yes. It helps to sort out which cap you mean, though, because two different things go by that name and people end up talking past each other.
To most people, a chimney cap is the metal piece on top of the flue liner. It keeps rain out of the flue, keeps birds and squirrels from moving in, and usually has a spark arrestor. That's a screen that stops sparks from flying out. I install those.
The other thing people call a cap is the masonry on top of the chimney. In the trade, that's a crown or a wash. It covers the top of the brick, and it's the part that decides how long the chimney lasts. There's more on why under Why do chimneys fall apart in the first place?
So I do both. If you tell me your cap is rusted through, I'll picture the metal one. If you tell me it's cracked and crumbling, I'll picture the masonry. If you send a photo, neither of us has to guess.
Does every chimney get the same crown?
No, and a mason who says otherwise hasn't looked at your chimney yet.
On most chimneys, a cast crown at least two inches thick with a drip edge is clearly the right thing to build. Two situations change that.
The first is a historic building, where the chimney has to stay the way it was first built. What the original mason built is the plan to follow, and a modern crown isn't part of it.
The second is a chimney with a corbelled top. That means the top rows of brick step out a little farther on each row to form the finished top. The chimney was designed around that detail. Setting a slab with a drip edge on top of it takes that away, and in my opinion it makes the chimney look wrong.
So it's a judgment call, and making that call is a big part of what you're paying a professional for. If the brick can be protected without wiping out the original mason's work, that's the way to go.
Can snow sliding off a metal roof knock a chimney down?
It can, and it does. Snow slides off a metal roof all at once, and there's nothing gentle about it. I've rebuilt several chimneys that took the hit, including cabins where the top of the chimney ended up out in the yard.
It's nearly always the same setup. There's a metal roof, a chimney below a long stretch of it, and no cricket built above the chimney. A cricket is a small peaked section of roof built behind the chimney. It splits the snow and sends it around the chimney. Where one is missing, rebuilding the chimney without adding a cricket just sets you up for the next rebuild. A cricket is roofing work, not masonry, so it's something to work out with your roofer. It's better to do that before the chimney goes back up than after.
Why is mortar falling out of my chimney or brickwork in large chunks?
Properly installed mortar wears away gradually, a little at a time. When it comes out in large chunks, the last repair was almost always done wrong.
The most common causes are joints that weren't cut out deep enough, mortar that is harder than the brick, joints that weren't cleaned or dampened first, and joints filled in one thick pass instead of thin layers. The standard is to cut old mortar out to two to two and a half times the width of the joint. A 3/8 inch joint should be cut out 3/4 to 1 inch deep. Shallow work has nothing to grip, so it pops out. Thin layers let the mortar cure evenly instead of shrinking away from the back of the joint. Weather matters too. Mortar that freezes or dries out too fast in wind or sun can fail early.
Another common cause is a skim coat of mortar smeared over the old joints without cutting anything out. That isn't a repair. It bonds poorly and falls off in pieces within a few seasons.
If mortar is coming out of your chimney in chunks, adding more on top won't fix it. The failed mortar has to be cut out and the joints redone correctly. I'm happy to look at it and tell you honestly what it needs.
My chimney cap has small cracks. Does it need to be replaced?
Not necessarily. Minor cracking in a chimney cap can be sealed with a high quality silicone sealant. If you check the cap every few years and re-caulk the cracks as they open up, the original cap may never need to be replaced. I won't recommend replacing a cap that doesn't need it.
This only applies to minor cracking. Wide cracks, crumbling, missing pieces, or a heavy cap poured over the top of an older chimney are different problems and usually need more than caulk.
Also look at the edge of the cap. If it has no drip edge, water runs straight down the face of the brick below it. Over the years that causes the brick to flake and crumble. Adding a drip edge helps protect the chimney below.
Sometimes a cap does have to come off, because the chimney underneath needs repair. When that's the case, I'll tell you plainly. If it doesn't, I'll tell you that too.
Why is the brick on my chimney cracking or flaking near the top?
A chimney cap without a drip edge is a common cause of this. Without a drip edge to direct water away, it runs straight down the face of the brick below the cap instead. Brick absorbs and releases moisture over time, and repeated freeze and thaw cycles wear at the surface where that water keeps hitting, which causes the brick to spall, flaking or crumbling at the surface. This kind of damage develops slowly, over years.
The fix is a new masonry crown with a proper drip edge, along with replacing the brick that has already spalled. The same issue often shows up on the sloped areas lower on the chimney, sometimes called the shoulders. Adding a matching cap with a drip edge there creates a sloped surface instead of a stepped one, which holds up better over time. Sealing the chimney can extend the life of the brick and mortar, but it's not a substitute for fixing a cap without a drip edge, and it doesn't guarantee that spalling won't continue.
My chimney has a huge concrete cap. Should it be removed or repaired?
A heavy concrete cap poured directly over an older chimney is more common than it should be, and it usually causes more problems than it solves. Removing a cap like that is aggressive enough that it often damages the chimney structure underneath, down to the roofline, which turns the job into a rebuild rather than a simple repair. If a full rebuild isn't in the budget right now, filling the cracks with caulk and keeping water out of them can buy some time. But it's not a one time fix. It turns into a maintenance task you'll need to stay on top of every few years for as long as that cap stays up there. Most customers find it's less hassle in the long run to have it addressed properly once.
Chimney repair projects
Real jobs, my own photos, and what the problem actually turned out to be.
Chimney rebuild, toppled by snow
A log cabin chimney knocked down by snow sliding off a metal roof, rebuilt from the ground up and faced in manufactured river rock.
Chimney repair: a deteriorating crown
A worn chimney crown and eroded brick rebuilt, with a new top liner section and a drip edge to keep water off the brick.
Chimney repair required by an insurer
A worn chimney the insurer required repaired: loose brick reset, joints repointed, top liner section repaired, new crown and drip edge.
Chimney rebuild after a failed stucco "repair"
A brick chimney that had been stuccoed over instead of repaired, taken down to the roofline and rebuilt in new brick.
Colonial-style chimney rebuild
A crumbling brick chimney taken down and rebuilt taller, with stepped rows of brick at the top to match the house's Colonial restoration.
Often needed alongside
Tuckpointing and repointing
Cutting out failed mortar and replacing it, matched as closely as the materials allow.
Tuckpointing and repointing →Inspection and consultation
A written condition report on brick, stone or chimneys, for when you need the assessment and not a bid.
Inspection and consultation →Masonry rebuilding
Impact damage put back the way it was: cars, forklifts, weather.
Masonry rebuilding →