Historic masonry restoration
Fackrell Masonry and Construction restores historic brick and stone buildings across Southern Idaho, repointing, replacing failed brick, and rebuilding chimneys to match the original work. Past projects include the 1865 Miners Exchange in Idaho City and Hangar 208 at Mountain Home Air Force Base.
Old buildings aren't complicated. They're just old. The Miners Exchange has stood on the boardwalk in Idaho City since 1865, and by the time we got to it the brickwork was at the end of its rope. A stair-step crack ran clear across the wall under the porch. The brick had come apart around the old wood lintels (the beams over the doors and windows). And the bottom rows of brick had worn away until there was more air than brick. It took new brick and the right mortar to buy that building another century. Nothing exotic. Just a whole lot of patience and the right mix.
That's how most restoration work goes. The Meridian Masonic Temple took the better part of a week of combing the building for damaged brick and open joints before anything got laid. On an old wall, what you can see from the sidewalk is a fraction of what's there. On Hangar 208 at Mountain Home Air Force Base the requirement was short to write down and long to do. Repair the damaged brick and repoint the mortar to match the original, on a building the Air Force intends to keep.
There's older work behind this too, from years before any of it reached a camera. That includes the masonry construction of the Blackfoot McDonald's, multiple United States Forest Service comfort stations, and the stone restoration of the Oregon Short Line Railroad Depot, now the Idaho Potato Museum. I don't have photographs of that work, but the buildings are still standing.
What this covers
- Failed brick cut out and replacements patched in, chosen to follow the size, shape and bond pattern of the original work
- Full repointing (cutting out the old mortar and packing in new) instead of spot repairs, so the joints look the same across a whole side of the building instead of in visible patches
- Mortar matched as closely as the materials allow. My dad and I built our own sample set over years of trial and error and it gets us to about 75%. You can't get an exact match on a weathered wall, and anybody who promises one hasn't done much of this
- A mix no harder than the masonry it's going into. That's the most important rule in restoration, and the National Park Service builds Preservation Brief 2 around it. Old brick is soft, and modern high-strength mortar won't give, so the faces of the brick flake off instead. That's called spalling. A great deal of the damage on historic buildings came from a well-meaning repair
- Laboratory analysis of the original mortar on the jobs that call for it, so the new mix is based on what the old one was made of instead of a guess from the ground
- The top of a chimney or stack rebuilt, then the shaft below it repointed
- Stair-step cracking, worn-away bottom rows of brick, and brick that's come apart around old wood lintels repaired
- Boom lift and scaffold work for walls, parapets and stacks a ladder won't reach
- Stone restoration as well as brick, including the stone on the Oregon Short Line Railroad Depot, now the Idaho Potato Museum
- Damaged brick and open joints found across the whole building, not just the ones showing from the sidewalk
Wondering what masonry repairs usually cost? See my cost guide.
How to tell you need this
- A crack that steps down through the mortar joints in a staircase pattern
- The bottom rows of brick at the sidewalk crumbled back until there's more air than brick
- Mortar joints you can rake out with a key, or joints washed out deep enough for moss to take hold
- Brick faces flaking or popping off. That's spalling, and on an old building it usually means a hard modern mortar went into a soft old wall at some point
- Brick coming apart above a door or window. It could be the old lintel (the beam over the opening) behind it, or it could be something else. Either way I'd have it looked at
- Loose brick at the top of a chimney or parapet, or pieces that have already come off
Questions people ask
Do you restore historic buildings in Idaho City, Boise and the rest of Idaho?
Yes. Fackrell Masonry and Construction has restored the Miners Exchange in Idaho City, the Meridian Masonic Temple, and Hangar 208 at Mountain Home Air Force Base. The service area is all of Southern Idaho, between the Oregon and Wyoming borders, as far north as McCall, Stanley, New Meadows and Salmon. Start with a quote by clicking here.
My house is old but it isn't a landmark. Is this the right page for me?
Probably, yes. Age is what matters here, not a plaque.
The reason this is its own page isn't paperwork. It's that old masonry behaves differently. Old brick was fired at lower temperatures, so it's softer. The lime-rich mortars made for it were softer still, on purpose. Both of those change what a repair has to be. An 1890s wall and a 1990s wall want different mortar, and treating the old one like the new one is how the faces end up coming off the brick.
So if your house is old, the approach on this page is the one your wall needs, whether or not anybody official has ever taken an interest in it.
A historic listing does matter for the paperwork around the work, and for any rules that come with grant money or a preservation easement. That's about process, not the masonry.
The faces are flaking off the brick on my old house. Can that be repaired?
The flaked brick itself, no. Once a face has popped off there's no putting it back, and nothing you spray or trowel on will bring it back either. What can be done is replacing the worst bricks and stopping whatever is causing it.
It's called spalling, and on an old building it usually comes from one of two things. The common one is a hard modern mortar that went into a soft old wall at some point. Something in a wall has to give with the seasons, and if the mortar won't, the brick does. The other is water getting into brick that's already porous and freezing inside it.
So the first step is figuring out why. If you replace spalled brick but leave hard mortar in the joints around it, the new brick starts spalling too, and you've paid for the job twice.
That's why, on an old building, the mortar question should come before the brick question.
Why does old brick need different mortar than new brick?
Because a wall has to have somewhere to move, and whatever's softest is where the movement goes.
Old brick was fired at lower temperatures and is comparatively soft. The lime-rich mortars built for it were softer still, on purpose, so the mortar took the movement from the seasons and wore away slowly while the brick stayed whole. Repointing a joint is cheap. Replacing a wall of ruined brick isn't.
Put a modern high-strength mix into that wall and it all flips. The mortar is now harder than the brick, so the brick becomes the part that gives, and the faces start popping off within a few winters.
It's also the most expensive mistake in old masonry, and almost nobody makes it on purpose. The strong modern mortar is what's sitting on the pallet at the supply yard. It's easier to buy and easier to work with, so somebody who's never worked on an old building grabs it, thinking he's doing you a favor. What it costs you is the face of the brick. Once the faces flake off there's no putting them back, and the only repair left is replacing the brick itself.
What does restoring an old brick building cost?
More per square foot than the same work on a modern building, and often less than people fear once they see what's actually needed.
What drives the price is mostly what I find. The Meridian Masonic Temple took the better part of a week just combing the building for damaged brick and open joints before anything got laid. On an old wall, what shows from the sidewalk is a fraction of what's there. That walk has to happen before anybody can put a real number on it. Anybody quoting an old building from the street is quoting a guess.
After that it's access, since parapets and stacks need a lift or scaffold. Then there's how much brick has to be replaced compared to how much just needs repointing, because replacing brick is much slower work. Last is whether the job calls for laboratory analysis of the mortar, which belongs on some buildings and is a waste of money on others.
I'd talk you out of doing a third of the building now and coming back in five years. You pay for the setup twice, and the color match gets harder, not easier.
Who's qualified to work on a historic building?
There's no registration for historic masons, and that's exactly the problem. Start with the legal minimum. Ask for the state registration number and look it up at the Idaho Division of Occupational and Professional Licenses. Check that masonry is the trade named on it, not a handyman code. Anybody who clears that bar can still bid your building, though, and the wrong choice on an old building can cost you for a hundred years.
So ask for proof instead. Ask what old buildings he's worked on, and whether you can go look at one. Ask what mortar he's proposing and why, because the right answer involves a soft mix and the wrong answer involves whatever was on the pallet at the supply yard. Ask how deep he's cutting the joints. And ask whether he's read the National Park Service Preservation Brief 2, or can at least describe what's in it without being prompted.
If you only ask one thing, ask what happens if the new mortar ends up harder than the brick. Anybody who has actually worked on old buildings will have a quick answer, and probably a strong opinion.
And if the building is listed, or there's preservation funding involved, there will be rules about the work and the paperwork. Find out what they are before you take bids, because they change the job.
Can you match the mortar on an old brick building?
Not exactly, and anybody who promises otherwise hasn't done much of this. The wall you're matching has been weathering for well over a century in some cases, so it's not the color the mortar was when it went in, and some of what went into it isn't made or mined anymore.
On an important building, a sample can go to a laboratory to find out what the original mortar was made of. Even then you don't get a twin. You get a mix based on the real thing instead of on somebody's eye. That gets to about 75%, and 75% is close enough that a repair looks like part of the wall instead of a patch.
Will the new mortar and brick look obvious when you're done?
Fresh mortar stands out against 150-year-old brick, and partway through a job like this the whole wall can look worse than it did on day one. That's normal, so I'm warning you now. It settles down as the mortar cures and weathers, and on a painted building like the Miners Exchange the paint goes back over it anyway.
Does the whole wall have to be repointed, or only the bad spots?
It depends how much of the wall has gone. On the Miners Exchange the whole wall came in, because the joints in between the obvious failures weren't holding much either.
On smaller jobs, customers often ask for a whole section to be repointed anyway so the color comes out even instead of patchy, and that's usually money well spent. I'll tell you which one your wall needs, even when the answer is less work instead of more.
Do you send the mortar off to a laboratory?
Only on jobs that call for it. Analysis costs real money and belongs on a large historic project where the specification calls for it. That's why the Hangar 208 stack got one. On a house, the same money does more good in the work itself, and you'll hear that from me instead of getting a bill for it.
Here's what the analysis gets you. It tells you what the old mortar is made of, so nobody has to eyeball it from the ground. It doesn't give you a twin, because there's no such thing. The sand came out of an Idaho riverbed a century ago, and nobody can go back and get more of it.
Have you done restoration work on government or landmark buildings?
Yes. The chimney stack on Hangar 208 at Mountain Home Air Force Base was a historical restoration, where the requirement was to repair the damaged brick and repoint the mortar to match the original. The family has also built multiple United States Forest Service comfort stations and did the stone restoration of the Oregon Short Line Railroad Depot, now the Idaho Potato Museum.
Historical restoration projects
Real jobs, my own photos, and what the problem actually turned out to be.
Miners Exchange, Idaho City
Brick repair and full repointing on the 1865 Miners Exchange in Idaho City, replacing failed brick and mortar so the walls hold another century.
Mountain Home Air Force Base, Hangar 208
Chimney restoration on Hangar 208 at Mountain Home Air Force Base: damaged brick replaced and the stack repointed with mortar mixed to a laboratory analysis of the original.
Meridian Masonic Temple
Repointing (new mortar in the joints) and brick repair on the Meridian Masonic Temple, with damaged brick and worn mortar found and replaced across the whole building.
Often needed alongside
Tuckpointing and repointing
Cutting out failed mortar and replacing it, matched as closely as the materials allow.
Tuckpointing and repointing →Chimney repair
Rebuilds, crowns, flue liner work and repointing.
Chimney repair →Commercial masonry
Storefronts, offices and public buildings, new and repaired.
Commercial masonry →