1. Mortar falling out in chunks
Good mortar wears away slowly, a little at a time, over decades. When a repair comes out in whole chunks, the joints were never prepared to hold it.
What poor work looks like
- New mortar coming out in clean, whole pieces within a few seasons of the repair.
- Chunks with a flat, smooth back. That's what mortar looks like when the joint behind it was cut too shallow, or not cut at all.
- Hairline cracks along the edges of the joints, where mortar packed in one thick pass shrank away from the brick.
How it should be done
- Old mortar cut out to two to two and a half times the width of the joint. On a 3/8 inch joint, that's 3/4 to 1 inch deep.
- Dust cleaned out and the joint dampened before any new mortar goes in.
- New mortar packed in thin layers, about a quarter inch at a time, each one firm before the next. Thin layers cure evenly instead of shrinking away from the back of the joint.
- The last layer tooled when it's thumbprint hard, so the joint is dense and sheds water.
Sources: National Park Service, Preservation Brief 2 and Brick Industry Association, Technical Notes 46
More on this: Why is mortar falling out of my chimney or brickwork in large chunks?